Bark and Training Collar Combo – 5 Signs It’s Not The Right One

bark and training collar combo

A bark and training collar combo for stubborn dogs can be valuable tools to help curb their barking habits or change their behavior. However, these kinds of collars come with controversy, and not all of these training collars are right for your pet.

How do you know if stubborn dog training collars are a good idea? And what’s the best dog bark collar?  The first step is knowing what you’re getting into with this type of training collar, and what kind works for various breeds.

What Is a Bark and Training Combo?

stop barking other dogs

A bark collar is a training collar meant to dissuade small dogs from barking too much. Usually, it’ll use negative reinforcement like increasingly sharp shocks on a dog’s neck to grab your dog’s attention and convince the dog to become quieter.

Similarly, training collars use shocks to help correct a dog’s behavior. Your pets would come to associate the unwanted behavior with an unpleasant sensation and so eventually reduce these behaviors.

A bark and training collar combo has both these features into one device. You can also set the device to emit a warning tone first before it shocks your pet. This will train your dog to recognize the tone and cease barking.

Some collars offer levels of vibration as well that it delivers before the device creates the static shock. The vibration will train your dog to recognize the warning before static shock is delivered by the device. It can be an effective way to correct your pet’s behaviour.

Choosing the Best Training Collar

When it comes to finding the best training bark collar combination, there are a few things you need to take into account.

Make sure you’re choosing a quality brand – there are a lot of cheap knock-offs out there that can actually do more harm than good. Once you’ve found a reputable brand, make sure to read up on the specific collar’s features and how to use it.

You should also be prepared to give your dog lots of positive reinforcement when he or she does well – treats, petting, and verbal praise are all great rewards.

small dog barking

Types of Bark and Dog Training Collars Combo

A combo bark and training collar uses methods like electric shocks, citronella fragrances, or high-pitched sounds to deter bad behaviour.

Most use a microphone or similar technique to detect when your dog is barking. Then the training collar will administer its particular deterrent to stop barking.

This type of train collar has proved to be a great success and yes, even the perfect solution to unwanted barks. The vibration can help correct undesirable behaviour and leave you with a trained pup.

There are training collars that would work as a virtual leash. It can control your pup as far as three-quarters of a mile away! These collars can work even without putting an actual leash on your pets. They can control your pet from far away.

Shocks Remote Training Collars

DOG CARE Dog Training Collar for Large Medium Dogs - Dog Shock Collar with Remote, Dog Training Collar with Beep, Vibration, Static Modes, Keypad Lock, 0-99 Adjustable Shock Levels, Long Remote Range
  • [Safety 4 Training Modes]: 3 intimate training modes (beep, vibration, 0-99 level shock mode) and a safety switch mode, which helps you to teach...
  • [1000ft Control Range & 9 Channels]: With training distances up to 1000ft, a stronger and more stable signal, DOG CARE training collars provide...
  • [2 Hours Quick Charge & Ultra-Long Run Time]: The rechargeable training collar can be quickly charged within 2 hours, the dog receiver collar can...

Electric shock training collars or e collars give out no more than a light zap to your pet, similar to when you touch a doorknob after rubbing socked feet on a carpet. It usually comes with a remote control that you can use to teach your pet how to behave. Some collars can have three training modes.

Of course, some organizations, like the SPCA, consider these kinds of bark collars to be far from being humane. The training collars can increase the intensity of the shocks and can potentially harm your dog more than you realize.

Before using a dog shock collar, test it on your hand. This will give you an idea of what it feels like to your dog before you use this collar to teach and train your pup.


Citronella Dog Training Collar with Remote Control,3 Using Modes Spray Vibration and Beep,Spray Dog Bark Collar,1000ft Range Harmless Safe Humane No Shock Anti-Bark
  • 【3 Training Modes & 3 Spray Levels】 – 【Note: This collar can only be used by the remote, can not work automatically when the dog...
  • 【Safe & Effective & Humane】 – Unlike electric shock collars, our citronella spray collar is extremely safe, effective and humane! It can...
  • 【Remote Control & Adjustable】 – Remote Range up to 1000 ft / 330 yards. Includes collar, remote controller, a can of citronella spray, USB...

These dog bark collars spray out citronella fragrances to shock your dog’s nose. As a dog has an extremely sensitive sniffer, citronella spray can seriously affect its ability to smell anything else for a while, and the strength of the collar odor will be uncomfortable for the dog.

Though they won’t cause any lasting physical damage to your pet, they can certainly seem like a harsh option. Your pups can become fearful of all kinds of noises including other dogs barking or sound from other animals.

You might want to look into a type of training that focuses more on positive reinforcement rather than harmful tone, vibration, and shock. Ask any professional dog trainer, and he would tell you this is a great option for training.


No products found.

Just like smells, both large and small dogs are sensitive to noise and sounds. They can be bothered by high pitches that humans can’t register.

These training collars use such sounds that only dogs can hear to make them think twice about unwanted barking. Though they won’t cause deafness, they will irritate most dogs and bring about some discomfort.

Signs a Bark and Training Collars Combo Isn’t Right for Your Dog

A bark and dog training collar combo is a tool to use alongside other training devices. It often comes with a remote controller that helps release stimulation. It’s not a method you should use all the time, and in many cases, it isn’t the right choice for a barking dog.

bark collar

Here are five signs you need to stop using these collars on your dog:

  • Your dog’s barking is getting worse
  • The dog bark control collar is physically harming your dog
  • Dog is becoming nervous and/or more terrified
  • Your dog is becoming aggressive
  • Has a lot of yappy friends

1. Barking is Getting Worse

If the bark control collar has the opposite effect on your dog, they might have become habituated to the stimulation. Habituation is when your dog learns to outsmart the bark training collar, uses it to their advantage, or learns to live with the punishment.

For instance, some dogs with a dog bark control collar might wait for the fragrance to be released before quickly moving away, so they are not affected by the smell.

When dogs become habituated, they no longer care about the shocks , smells, or sounds a dog bark collar will administer. This habituation results in them not learning to curb their behavior and instead reinforces the idea that they can create as much noise as they want.

Some dogs gain self-confidence by outsmarting collars and devices and bark even more than usual to assert their dominance over a bark control or dog training collar.

2. Bark Collar is Physically Harming Your Dog

Especially for small or young dogs, bark and dog training combo collars might be too heavy for some dog breeds. For puppies, in particular, their skin is more fragile and can easily tear under the weight of a training collar.

If your dog is getting lacerations or cuts from wearing the collar, the dog owner needs to find a different training method. Additionally, if your dog is easily disoriented, a training collar might make them confused and distressed.

Your pet might try to get away from the shock, sound, or smell and end up harming themselves in the process.

right bark collar dog starts barking

3. Increased Nervousness

If your dog suffers from a disability or other issue, a combo collar might do more harm than good. Issues like deafness, brain diseases, or other cognitive problems could result in your dog barking more than average. If they can’t help their excessive barking, a combo collar will only make them unnecessarily uncomfortable.

They won’t understand why they’re being punished and can become more nervous, yappier, and terrified all the time. In these cases, combo collars can be traumatizing to your dog and should not be a training tool.

4. Increased Aggressiveness

Similar to the above, if your dog has increased aggressive behavior, it might be because of an outstanding issue. If your dog barks for a specific reason, such as nervousness or separation anxiety, using a combo caller might worsen the problem.

Your dog could become traumatized or distressed, causing them to overreact to situations and potentially attacking other dogs, dog owners, or yourself.

Aggression can also come from habituation. If your dog learns to ignore its combo collar, you will unlikely control them in other ways. If they can become habituated with any punishment you dole out, they can become more aggressive and challenging to manage.

When your dog becomes more aggressive after experiencing a combo collar, dog owners should stop using it and try to find a new way to perform dog training and ensure bark control. If you can’t reverse their newfound aggression, you might have to give up your dog.

5. Your Dog’s Friends Bark Too

If you have your dog wear a collar to train them not to bark at other dogs, you could be running the risk of punishing them unfairly.

Most bark and training collars don’t distinguish between your dog’s bark and another dog’s bark. So, if you take your dog to the park or around the neighborhood where there are other yappy dogs, the bark collar might respond accordingly.

Even if your dog isn’t barking, their shock collar could pick up the barks of other dogs and administer a shock, smell, or sound. This shock means your dog becomes punished for other dogs’ barks, which is both unfair and confusing to your pet.

If your dog feels attacked by their collar, they could become distressed, nervous, or aggressive no matter their behavior.

dog owners large dogs best spray bark collar

Talk to Your Vet

It’s vital to your pet’s health never to use these collars if your dog has a pre-existing condition like deafness. Talk to your vet beforehand to see if a bark and dog training combo would be a good idea for your dog.

How to Choose the Right Combo Collar?

If you feel that you need to invest in these type of training collars to help train your pets, you might as well know what to consider to get the best one for your pup.

A Good Range

First off, you might want something that has a long control range. You would find one that has a range of up to 100 feet or more, which would allow you to work with your pet from a considerable distance.

For hunting dogs, you might want to get something with a much longer range. You can actually find one with a range of 1600 feet, which is a good range for when you’re training a hunt dog.

The range of your collar can guarantee that you would be able to pull your pup out of trouble easily.


Ideally, if you are going to invest money into an e collar, you should take into account the quality of the product. You want something that is waterproof so it will be able to withstand bad weather if you and your pooch gets caught out in the rain.

Look for a product that is waterproof even when it receives a spray of water.

Guarantees Safety

Your collar may not be gentle, but it should at least ensure the safety of your pooch when you use it for training. It may not be as “humane” as you might want, but it should at least not hurt your pup – just give it some form of stimulation or quick jolt after a tone and vibration.

You especially want a collar that is gentle on smaller dogs. So, you might want to get two sets of training collars – one collar for large dogs and another collar for smaller pets.

dog doesn't feel shock collar

Remote Access

Ideally, you should have remote access to your training collar, so you can trigger stimulation or shocks even from a distance. This would be perfect for outdoor remote training, hunting, or field trips with your pup.

The remote control would hibernate when you’re not using it, but it would wake up instantly once you push a button. The remote controller would help enable or disable the collar’s features when needed.

Great Customer Support

If you’re going to invest your hard-earned money on a training collar, you should consider getting your e-collar from a company with great customer support. They should be able to help you determine if the products suit your pets.

They should have accessible and supportive customer assistance. Check out reviews and buy from companies that stock collars that have been tested and proven effective but kind to pets.

What’s the Best Dog Bark Collar?

Looking for the best bark collar? Here are the best options:

1. PetSafe GentleSpray Anti-Bark Dog Collar

This collar is a great option for those who are looking for an humane way to train their dog to stop barking. The GentleSpray Anti-Bark Dog Collar uses a burst of citronella spray to interrupt your dog’s barking and help him or her associate the behaviour with a negative consequence.

2. SportDOG NoBark Spray Collar

SportDOG Brand NoBark SBC-8 Bark Control Collar - Shock Collar with Progressive Correction - Waterproof - Static Stimulation - Dogs 8 lbs & up
  • SILENT PARTNER TECHNOLOGY: This bark control shock collar detects barking by using our patented technology that quickly determines your dog's...
  • PROGRESSIVE CORRECTION: Static correction starts at the lowest level and increases each time your dog barks within 30 seconds of the previous...
  • SIZING: Collar fits dogs 8 pounds or larger with neck sizes 5" - 22"

If you’re looking for an affordable bark collar that still offers quality performance, the SportDOG NoBark Spray Collar is a great option. This collar uses bursts of harmless citronella spray to deter your dog from barking and can be used on dogs of all sizes.

3. Petsafe Elite Little Dog Bark Control Trainer

The Petsafe Elite Little Dog Bark Control Trainer is perfect for small dogs who bark excessively. This collar uses safe static correction to stop your little dog from barking and can be adjusted to fit dogs of different weights and sizes.

4. Garmin Delta XC Sonic Birdhouse Bark Control

Garmin Delta XC Bundle - dog training device
  • LONG/SHORT CONTACTS : Includes long and short changeable/replaceable contact points ; Collar compatibility: 1.9 centimeter (0.75 inch).Control...
  • STIMULATION LEVELS : Improved stimulation levels; features 18 levels of momentary and continuous stimulation, plus tone and vibration
  • RANGE : Gives 1/2 mile range capability to correct your dog’s behavior while out in the field

The Garmin Delta XC Sonic Birdhouse Bark Control is a high-tech bark collar that uses ultrasonic sound waves to deter your dog from barking. This collar is perfect for stubborn barkers and can be used on dogs of all sizes.

5. ThunderShirt Classic Dog Anxiety Jacket

ThunderShirt for Dogs, Large, Heather Gray Classic - Dog Anxiety Relief Calming Vest
  • ThunderShirt is already used by millions of dogs and may help alleviate anxiety symptoms in your dog
  • Recommended for thunder, fireworks, separation anxiety, travel, general anxiety and vet visits*
  • Vet recommended and very easy to use; ThunderShirt is safe and drug-free*

If your dog suffers from anxiety or fear-related barking, the ThunderShirt Classic Dog Anxiety Jacket may be a good solution. This jacket uses gentle pressure to calm your dog and can be used on dogs of all sizes

6. SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425S Digital Dog Training Shock Collar

SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425X Dog Training Collar - 500 Yard Range - Rechargeable Remote Trainer with Static, Vibrate, and Tone
  • 500 YARD RANGE: e-collar that can support training up to 3 dogs with the same remote with purchase of additional collars (SDR-AXS). For dogs 8...
  • NO LOOK OPERATION: Designed for ease-of-use and no look operation while offering more levels of stimulation which allows for more customized...
  • TONE, VIBRATE, AND STIM: This electric e collar offers 21 levels of static stimulation with medium/high ranges. Option to train with vibration...

This collar offers 16 levels of stimulation, perfect for any size dog, as well as a waterproof design that makes it perfect for use outdoors.

7. YS500 Anti-Bark Electronic No Barking Control Collar

This collar also offers seven adjustable levels of stimulation, as well as an automatic stop after 30 minutes to prevent over-stimulation in your dog.

Should I Use a Bark Collar?

Deciding whether or not you should use an anti bark collar is a tough decision, but it’s important to remember why they were created in the first place. Anti bark collars can be incredibly helpful tools when used responsibly, as/since they can help curb disruptive barking and help your pet become more obedient.

But if you’re considering using one, it’s crucial to get familiar with how anti bark collars work and their potential safety risks. You should also think about why your pet might be barking and find other methods of addressing the behaviour instead of relying solely on anti bark collars.

Just remember that anti bark collars are not necessarily the only answer when it comes to tempering your pup’s (sometimes overly) vocal habits.


Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs

If you have a stubborn dog, it can be difficult to train them and keep them from misbehaving. A training collar can be an effective tool for controlling and correcting your pet’s behavior. There are many types of collars available, so finding the right one for your pup can be a challenge. Here are some tips for choosing the best training collar for stubborn dogs.

Start by researching different types of collars to determine which one is best suited for your pup’s temperament and breed type. A good quality training collar should be comfortable, adjustable, and durable. Look for collars that are made with materials such as nylon and leather, which will hold up to wear and tear, and be gentle on your pup’s skin.

Once you have selected the type of collar that is most suitable for your pup, consider the different features available. Some collars are equipped with vibration or sound functions that can be used to discourage bad behavior. Others come with remote control capabilities for more precise corrections. Consider the type of training you’ll be doing and how the collar will be used when selecting one with specific features.

Make sure that any training collar you select is adjustable so it can grow with your pup. You should also look for a collar that is waterproof and rust-resistant if your pup enjoys swimming or gets wet frequently.

When training your pup, it is important to use the collar correctly and humanely. Be sure to read all instructions thoroughly and consult with a professional trainer if necessary. Training collars can be an effective tool for controlling your pet’s behavior, but you should always take care to use them safely and responsibly.

Do Vibrating Bark Collars Need Remotes?

No, not all vibrating bark collars require a remote. Some models are activated by sound and vibration from your pet’s barking, so they do not need a remote. However, if you want to have more precision while training your pup with the collar, it is best to opt for one that includes a remote control feature. This will allow you to customize the settings and make corrections in a gentle and precise manner.

What’s the Best Dog Bark Collar?

It’s a tough decision when trying to choose the best bark collar for up to three dogs. Not only do you have to consider the unique needs and personalities of each pup, but also factors such as size, material, water-resistance and even how stylish it is!

The good news is that advances in pet technology means there are now some great options available with features designed to curb barking without causing any harm to your beloved pups.

It might take some research, but once you’ve identified the perfect dog bark collar for your furry four-legged friends, you can look forward to peaceful days and nights filled with plenty of cuddles from your canine companions.

What are the Citronella Dog Collar Side Effects?

Citronella bark collars have become increasingly popular for pet owners looking for an alternative to more intimidating anti-barking devices. However, citronella bark collars are not a miracle solution and can come with some potential side effects that dog owners should be aware of.

Although citronella collars have typically been met with a favorable response from dogs, overuse may lead to skin irritation or allergies to the citronella oil. In addition, citronella collars may disrupt the relationship between pet and owner due to feelings of discomfort from both parties towards the citronella collar.

But if used responsibly and in moderation, citronella bark collars still offer an effective way for dog owners who want to reinforce good behavior in their four-legged friends without having to resort to fear tactics.

Do Bark Collars Really Work?

With dogs being known as man’s best friend, it’s no surprise that some pet owners go to extreme measures to keep them from barking so loudly. Enter bark collars – the controversial tool used to discourage nuisance barking.

There have been mixed reviews on whether or not these devices really work, but it seems like one thing everyone can agree on is that getting a bark collar for your pup definitely isn’t an easy choice and you can’t always rely on opinions from other dog owners.

Ultimately, the success of any anti-barking device will depend on how diligent you are in understanding your pup’s needs and adjusting the settings accordingly.

Bark and Training Collars Combo – Conclusion

Bousnic Dog Shock Collar for 2 Dogs - (8-120lbs) Waterproof Rechargeable Electric Dog Training Collar with Remote for Small Medium Large Dogs with Beep Vibration Safe Shock Modes(Grey)
12,239 Reviews
Bousnic Dog Shock Collar for 2 Dogs - (8-120lbs) Waterproof Rechargeable Electric Dog Training Collar with Remote for Small Medium Large Dogs with Beep Vibration Safe Shock Modes(Grey)
  • 🔥Perfect for Training, Simple and Effective: Our electric shock collar is designed with 3 extremely effective harmless modes: beep(standard),...
  • 🔥Dual-Channel with Up to Almost 1000FT Range: Our remote features a dual-channel to support training 2 dogs simultaneously. The remote...
  • 🔥Sleeker, Smaller and More Lightweight, Comfortable for All Sizes of Dogs: This our e collar Receiver is mini. Meas.2.3(L)*1.4(W)*1(H)inch....

Using a bark and training collar combo sparingly with other training methods will help your dog learn proper behavior with continuous and momentary stimulation. If the bark collar has adverse effects, this could be a sign it’s not suitable for your dog.

If your dog continues to bark, acts aggressive, nervous, or starts to get hurt, stop using the bark collar and find a different training method.

CLICK HERE to shop our complete selection of high quality, durable dog products!

Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top