Bark Collar: Is It Safe to Use?

bark collar

Bark collar is a type of electronic training device that is used to stop dogs from barking. They work by emitting an ultrasonic sound or a static shock when the dog barks. Electronic bark collars are controversial, and there is a lot of debate over whether they are safe or not.

In this blog post, we will take a look at the pros and cons of using bark collars, and we will give you our opinion on whether we think they are safe or not. Apart from that we will check which is the best bark collar in the market.

Table of Contents

What Is A Bark Collar?

best spray bark collar nbju bark collar

A bark collar is a type of collar that is designed to stop a dog from barking. The collar gives a choker chain or prong shock when the dog barks. There are also ultrasonic and citronella bark collars that work by emitting a high pitched noise or spray of citronella, respectively during nuisance barking.

Bark collars are used to train dogs not to bark excessively. This is usually done by first teaching the dog what it should bark at and then teaching the dog not to bark at things that are not threats or important. For example, a dog might be taught that it should bark at people who come into the house, but not bark at people who walk by the house.

Once the dog understands what it should bark at, the bark collar can be used to stop the dog from barking at things that are not threats or important. Bark collars can be effective in reducing or eliminating excessive barking, but they should only be used as a last resort after other methods, such as positive reinforcement training, have failed.

Types Of Bark Collar

dog owners large dogs best spray bark collar

Spray/Citronella Collar:

Spray collars are very popular because they are gentle and work well. When the spray collar is put around the dog’s neck, citronella, which smells like lemon, is sent toward and into the dog’s nose every time it barks.

Most of the time, when a dog is upset, it will make the connection between barking and the bad smell. This can help the dog learn to control itself better. Still, some dogs may get used to the smell of citronella, which would make the product worse for the owners and not stop the dog from barking.

Beep Collar:

When the dog barks, the beep collar makes a sound that only dogs can hear. Dogs might not like this sound, so you could teach them not to bark so they won’t hear it.

This option is usually best for smaller dogs, but it might not work as well because it’s hard to know how the dog will react to the sound because some dogs are much more delicate than others. This collar can also come with fixed stations that can be put around the house in places where the dog tends to bark the most (near a doorway or window for example).

Vibration Collars:

When the dog barks, the vibrating anti-bark collar sends a vibrational stimulation to surprise the dog and change its attention. This option is becoming more and more popular with pet owners as a safe way to train vocal dogs. It is painless and works on dogs of all sizes.

right bark collar dog starts barking

Shock Collar:

Shock collars are one of the most controversial ways to stop dogs from barking. They send an electric shock to the dog’s neck. This collar is not recommended because there are safer and more humane ways to stop dogs from barking.

Ultrasonic Dog Collar:

When your dog barks, the collar sends out a high-frequency sound that hurts the dog’s ears and scares the dog. Most of the time, these collars are cheaper and don’t need refills. But because the punishment is noise, other pets in the house will also be hurt. People can’t hear it, so it won’t bother you. You also won’t be able to tell if it’s working or not.

There are a few options. Below, you can see a collar with two sensors and a device with one sensor that is not a collar. Keep in mind that a single sensor could be set off by sounds other than your dog barking. Since the device isn’t meant to be worn around your dog’s neck, it might also scare other animals.

Pros And Cons Of Using Bark Collar

bark collar

A Shock Collar’s Pros

The collar helps to give dogs a mild electrical shock which can be monitored from afar. If a dog barks or tries to run away, it gets a punishment right away that makes it stop.

It’s easy to give the right amount of shock from afar. It is very important to carefully adjust the shock, because if it is too strong, the dog may become stressed or afraid. Too little force and the dog will not care.

Shock Collars Cons

Trainers of dogs have been interested in the bad things about a shock collar. Even if the voltage is set too high by accident, the treatment is thought to be cruel. Skin on a person is different from skin on a dog, and the dog may feel the pain more strongly.

Shock collars have been shown to make some dogs more aggressive, stressed, afraid, and helpless. They get confused and angry because they can’t do what comes naturally to them when they’re in danger.

Dogs who were trained with shock collars had more of the stress hormone in their bodies. They show that they have learned to feel helpless by yawning and having tense bodies. These dogs might learn to stay alone whenever they are around something bad.

Shock collars are against the law in England, Austria, Spain, Denmark, Germany, Sweden, and Scotland, among other European countries.

Ultrasonic Collar Pros

As the holder, you won’t hear the bad sound that the dog hears. This makes less noise, which helps keep the peace. This collar also assists the dog’s barking behavior, but it doesn’t hurt the dog like a shock collar does.

Ultrasonic Collar Cons

A problem with this collar is that it could be set off by sounds other than barks. The dog’s movement can set it off, whenever the collar is set off by vibration. When the collar is set off by the sound of the dog’s barking, it can also be set off by other sounds, like a baby crying or a car passing by.

False alarms are less likely to happen with newer, higher-end models. Other anti bark collars for dogs cost between $25 and $50. Models that are smarter and more sensitive to control excessive barking can cost between $100 and $400.

Spray Collar’s Pros

Spray collars cost less than the other anti-barking collar. This is a much humane bark collar, however some dogs learn to jump back when the spray is used. But even when this happens, the smell is still bad.

Spray Collar Cons

Static shock collar, vibration collars and ultrasonic bark collar are crueler than spray bark collars. However, there may still be psychological effects to dogs.

Static Bark Collar’s Pros

A static bark collar is a milder form of bark collar. It gives the dog a small electric shock that feels like a tingling sensation.

The more expensive brands have an automatic safety shut off. This will let pet parents stop the critical stimulus when they want the dogs to bark, like if there is a fire or someone is breaking in.

Static Bark Collar’s Cons

The problem with all bark collars is that they might stop your dog from barking when there’s something wrong. If the power goes out, your dog might not be able to bark to warn you.

This Petsafe bark collar is designed so that they don’t overcorrect or under correct bad behavior, and they come with remote control.

How Dog Bark Collars Work

long haired dogs best bark collars

Have you ever wondered how a barking collar works? It’s pretty simple. A barking collar is a device that is worn around a dog’s neck. It has sensors that detect dog’s excessive barking. When the dog barking collars detect excessive barking, it sends a signal to the large dog’s collar.

The bark dog collar then delivers a mild electric shock to the dog. The shock is not enough to hurt the dog, but it is enough to startle him and get his attention. The bark collar is a training tool that is used to teach dogs not to bark excessively.

Bark collars are safe and effective when used properly, and they can be a great way to train your dog. The Dog owner is considering using an anti bark collar especially for large dogs. Be sure to consult with your veterinarian first to make sure it is the best bark collar for their large dog.

Shock Collar Alternatives

Positive Reinforcement Training

Dog’s bark collar alternative is positive reinforcement training. This type of training uses rewards to train dogs not to bark excessively.

The most common reward is food, but you can also use toys or praise. With positive reinforcement training, the goal is to teach the dog that he will get a reward if he does not bark excessively.

This type of training takes patience and time, but it can be very effective.

best bark collars dog starts barking

Citronella Collar

Another dog’s bark collar alternative is a citronella spray collar. Spray collars release citronella when dog’s bark excessively. Citronella is a safe and a non-toxic substance that smells bad to dogs, so it gets their attention without harming them hence stop dog’s barking

Citronella collars are not as effective as bark collars, but they are a good option for dogs who are sensitive to sound or electric shocks.

Use A Clicker Or Whistle Pet Owner Training Dog Using Whistle

You don’t have to use a training collar to encourage good behavior. You can use a clicker or a whistle instead. Some professional dog trainers add these techniques to positive reinforcement training to make it more effective.

Add a verbal cue after using the whistle or clicker to train your puppy. Once he gets the hang of it, you may not need to use the whistle or clicker anymore, just your verbal cues.

Husher Method

A Husher is another way to stop a dog’s barking. This is an elastic muzzle that goes around your dog’s mouth and stops it from opening all the way to bark. Even with a Husher on, your dog should still be able to eat, drink, and pant.

They can be used as a training tool. For example, if your dog is barking and you tell it to stop and it doesn’t, you can put the Husher on it. Based on cortisol levels, some studies have shown that hushers are less stressful for dogs than other types of bark collars.

Harmful Risk Of Using Dog Bark Collar

long haired dogs automatic collar

Has Physiological Reactions To Spray Bark Collar

If you’ve ever wondered why your dog has such a strong reaction to the bark collar, it’s because the spray bark collar has physiological reactions. When the collar is sprayed, it triggers a release of histamine and other chemicals in the body that cause an allergic reaction.

This is why dogs will often scratch, rub their eyes, and have difficulty breathing after being sprayed by a bark collar. In some cases, the reaction can be so severe that it requires medical attention.

However, most dogs will recover within a few minutes with no lasting effects. So, if you’re looking for a way to help train your dog without causing them undue stress, bark collars may not be the best option.

Pain Can Result To Redirected Aggression

Dogs bark for a variety of reasons, including boredom, fear, anxiety, and excitement. For some dog owners, this can be nuisance barking, especially if the dog’s barking is constant or loud. Bark collars are one way to try to reduce excessive dog’s barking.

However, bark collar results in redirected aggression that can occur when a dog perceives the bark collar as a threat. This may cause the dog to become aggressive towards other dogs or people, even if they are not the source of the bark collar.

In some cases, this redirected aggression can be severe and may even lead to bites. Therefore, it is important to be aware of the potential risks before using a bark collar on your dog. If you do decide to use a bark collar, be sure to closely monitor your dog’s behavior and consult with a trainer or behaviorist if you see any signs of aggression.

training collar best bark collars

Equipment Malfunction

The anti-bark collar often does not work (Polsky 1994). The device can be set off by a noise in the area or by a dog growling. This can cause dissociation, which can make the person feel more anxious, confused, and angry.


bark collar results in lesions because of the electric pulse that it emits to stop a dog from barking. The bark collar gives off an electric pulse that goes through the dog’s neck and causes a brief, mild shock. This bark collar.

Results in Lesions can be painful for your dog and may cause him to yelp or cry. In some cases, bark collar results to Lesions can also lead to more serious injuries, such as burns or electrical shocks.

If you’re using a bark collar on your dog, be sure to follow the manufacturer’s instructions carefully and check the bark collar regularly for signs of damage. Also, keep an eye on your dog while he’s wearing the bark collar to make sure he doesn’t seem to be in pain or distress. If you have any concerns about a bark collar resulting in lesions, speak to your veterinarian.

Prevents Dog From Its Natural Behavior

If you’ve ever been out for a walk with your dog and had them bark at another dog, only to be corrected by a bark collar, you may have wondered why the bark collar is considered to be an effective training tool. After all, doesn’t it just deny your dog the opportunity to engage in natural behavior?

The truth is, bark collars can be an effective training tool – but only when used correctly. When bark collars are used consistently and correctly, they can help your dog learn to control their barking. However, if bark collars are used incorrectly, or if they’re not suited for your dog’s personality, they can actually do more harm than good.

Vibration Bark collars work by emitting a corrective stimulus – usually a noise or a vibration – when your dog barks. Vibration bark collar produces a corrective stimulus designed to interrupt a dog’s barking. Over time, the dog will learn that their barking results in the corrective stimulus, and they’ll start to bark less as a result.

Do Not Solve Dog’s Problem

bark control collar results show that the bark collar is not a very effective tool in dealing with canine behavior issues. In fact, the bark collar results show that the bark collar can actually make some behavior problems worse. The bark collar works by delivering a shock to the dog when it is barking.

The problem with this is that it does not address the underlying issue that is causing the dog to bark in the first place. For example, if the dog is barking because it is anxious or stressed, then the bark collar is not going to help the dog learn to cope with its anxiety. In fact, the bark collar may even make the anxiety worse.

If you are thinking about using a bark collar to stop your dog from barking, you should first consult with a professional trainer or behaviorist to see if there are better ways to deal with your dog’s behavior issue.

Tips in Using Dog Bark Collars

stop barking nbju bark collar

Dog Wore The Collar For At Least Two Weeks Before It Was Turned On.

This will assist the dog become used to its specific device before it knows what it will be used for. For the first few times the dog wears the collar, the owner should stay close by and keep the dog on using Regal leash in case the collar comes off by accident. When the dog is used to wearing its new collar, it can be turned on. 

Carefully Read The Instructions For How To Use The Dog Bark Collar To Make Sure The Animals Are Safe And That It Works.

Be sure to keep the dog bark collar in good working condition. Check it regularly to make sure it is not damaged, and make sure the batteries are fresh.

Bark collars can be an effective tool in training your dog, but they should be used with care and caution. If you have any concerns about using a dog bark collar, be sure to consult with your veterinarian first.

Anti-bark Collar Shouldn’t Be Worn On Walks, And They Shouldn’t Be On The Dog For More Than 12 Hours A Day.

If the dog is bark collar-trained, the owner should still be able to bark on command. The dog bark collar should only be used as a last resort after other training methods have failed.

Bark collars can be an effective tool in training your dog, but they should be used with care and caution. If you have any concerns about using a bark collar, be sure to consult with your veterinarian first.

Find The Reason Why Your Dog Usually Barks

Dogs bark for many reasons, including boredom, fear, anxiety, and hunger. If you can find the reason why your dog is barking, you can try to address the issue and train them not to bark.

For example, if your dog is bored, try giving them more toys or taking them on more walks. If your dog is anxious, try training them with positive reinforcement. If your dog is hungry, try feeding them more often or giving them more food.

Barking is a natural behavior for dogs, and it’s important to allow them to bark sometimes. When you understand why your dog is barking, it is better to teach it to do something else rather than barking.

For instance, if your dog barks whenever the buzzer rings, tell him to linger before you open the front door and give him a treat when he is quiet. He will try to sit rather than bark if he does it over and over again. Two useful commands to teach your dog are “quiet” and “sit.”

training collar best bark collars

Reward The Right Behavior

When you punish your dog for training it, you must also praise it when it does the right thing. This is essential since if you only tell your dog “no,” it will find another way to act that might not be good either. By giving a treat for the right answer, you can get your furry best friend to do what you want.

DO NOT Use A Dog Bark Collar Until Your Dog Knows How To Do Simple Things.

Start with basic commands such as sit, come, down, etc. When your dog masters those, you can move on to more difficult tricks and behaviors.

It is also important that your dog associates the bark collar with positive things. For example, put the bark collar on before going for a walk or giving your dog a treat.

With this, you’ll know they understand what you’re asking them to do, and they’ll be able to link any bad behavior to the “shock.”

Only Buy A Dog Bark Collar With Two Sensors.

These only work when the device picks up both the sound of the dog barking and a vibration in its throat. Most of the time, this keeps the collar from being turned on by other dogs or sounds outside. AVOID at all costs the cheap ones!

Choose A Barking Dog Collar That Has Multiple Levels Of Punishment:

Each dog is sensitive to a shock, sound, or smell in a different way, just like each person is (punishers). If the device can be set to different levels, you might be able to find the one that will teach your dog to stop barking.

automatic safety shut off stop barking

A Warning Sign Before The Unpleasant Thing Is Best:

Some collars make a sound or shake to warn the dog that it is about to get shocked. This lets the dog stop barking and keep from getting hit. Over time, dogs learn to be quiet when the alarm goes off. This cuts down on how often the animal is shocked.

Attend A Training Program

No matter which collar you choose, you MUST also follow a program to stop your dog from barking. This will help your dog learn faster and, over time, help you and your dog stop needing the collar.

Best Bark Collars in the Market

SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers

SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425X Dog Training Collar - 500 Yard Range - Rechargeable Remote Trainer with Static, Vibrate, and Tone
  • 500 YARD RANGE: e-collar that can support training up to 3 dogs with the same remote with purchase of additional collars (SDR-AXS). For dogs 8...
  • NO LOOK OPERATION: Designed for ease-of-use and no look operation while offering more levels of stimulation which allows for more customized...
  • TONE, VIBRATE, AND STIM: This electric e collar offers 21 levels of static stimulation with medium/high ranges. Option to train with vibration...

SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers is one of the best dog bark training collar in the market. It has 21 levels of adjustment, a beep-only option, a battery that can be charged, and a range of 500 yards.

This collar costs more than some other electronic options, but it gives you more control and, as a result, makes training your dog a more positive experience. It also lets you train your dog with 21 levels of a much milder tingle instead of starting with a strong shock. This dog training collar is one of our top choices.

PetSpy M686 Premium Dog Training Shock Collar

PetSpy M686 Premium Dog Training Shock Collar, 1100 Yards, Medium to Large Dogs, with Vibration, Electric Shock and Beep, Waterproof, Remote Trainer (One Dog)
  • Good for professional trainers and first-time dog parents
  • 4 training modes: continuous shock, 1 sec shock, vibration, and a beep trainer with 8 adjustable levels
  • Waterproof collar with remote control range up to 1100 yards, good for all dog breeds from 10-140 lbs

If you can’t afford the SportDOG collar, the PetSpy M686 Premium Training Collar is another best bark collar choice. It has four ways to train: vibration, sound, short shocks, and long shocks. It also has eight levels of vibration and shock that you can change, so you can fine-tune the level of correction.

We also like that the contact points on this collar are made of conductive rubber, which won’t irritate the skin. It has a huge range (up to 1,100 yards), and the remote control has a handy strap that makes it easy to carry. The collar is waterproof and can fit most dogs between 10 and 140 pounds (but not the remote).

Paipaitek Dog Training Collar No Shock

The PatPet 356A dog training collar is the best one we’ve seen for less than $40. It gets great reviews from customers, works well, and has most of the features you’ll need if you don’t need a long range (its range is roughly 330 yards).

This inexpensive training collar has a waterproof collar, safety silicone caps for the prongs, and three training modes: beep, vibration (1-8 levels), and static shock (1-16 levels). It fits many dogs because the neck size can be changed from 7.8 inches to 27 inches (around 15 to 100 pounds).

DOG CARE Dog Training Vibration Bark Collar

DOG CARE Dog Training Collar for Large Medium Dogs - Dog Shock Collar with Remote, Dog Training Collar with Beep, Vibration, Static Modes, Keypad Lock, 0-99 Adjustable Shock Levels, Long Remote Range
  • [Safety 4 Training Modes]: 3 intimate training modes (beep, vibration, 0-99 level shock mode) and a safety switch mode, which helps you to teach...
  • [1000ft Control Range & 9 Channels]: With training distances up to 1000ft, a stronger and more stable signal, DOG CARE training collars provide...
  • [2 Hours Quick Charge & Ultra-Long Run Time]: The rechargeable training collar can be quickly charged within 2 hours, the dog receiver collar can...

DOG CARE Dog Training Collar has three training modes (beep, vibration, and 0-99 level shock mode) and a safety switch mode that helps you teach your dog basic obedience commands and solve problems with behavior that you can’t control.

With a signal that is stronger and more stable and a training range of up to 1000 feet, DOG CARE training collars give you the freedom to train your dog in large spaces. You can train up to 9 dogs with just 1 remote transmitter.

DOG CARE IP67 waterproof training collar lets dogs play without worrying about getting wet. Wear it without worrying about wading or being afraid of mud to meet the needs of multi-scene training. This gives you the most freedom in outdoor activities without hurting the receiver.

PATPET Dog Shock Collar with Remote

PATPET Dog Training Collar with Remote - Electric Dog Shock Collar for Small Medium Large Dogs - 3 Adjustable Safe Modes, Rechargeable Waterproof E Collar for Dogs (8-120 lbs)
  • Powerful Remote Control Function: If you want to train two dogs through one remote, 680 can meet your needs. It features a robust remote control...
  • Multiple Training Modes and Adjustable Options: : Provides 3 Safe effective humane training modes. Customized static shock (1-16) levels,...
  • 2 Hour Quick Charge & Longer Battery Life : After 2-hour fully charging, Supporting 40-60 days training sessions. Additionally, it offers...

PATPET Dog Shock Collar with Remote offers 3 safe, effective, and kind ways to train. Customizable static shock (1–16 levels), standard vibration mode, and standard “Tone” mode. The security switch stops the remote from being used in the wrong way.

The collar can work for 30 days after a full 2-hour charge, and the remote can work for 60 days. A low battery indicator on both the remote and the receiver lets you know when it’s time to charge.

The nylon collar can be changed to fit dogs with neck sizes from 7″ to 27″. Stronger and smaller collar, perfect for all sizes of dogs (8 pounds to 120 pounds), even puppies.

Frequently Asked Questions

only the dog breed

How Does A Shock Collar Work? How Long Do Dogs Wear Bark Collars?

Dogs wear bark collars around their neck and delivers a form of negative reinforcement when the dog barks. The most common type of bark collar uses an electronic sensor to detect when the dog barked and then delivers a static shock, ultrasonic bark collars, or spray bark collar of citronella or lemon juice.

 Bark collars gets active by vibration instead of bark. It is triggered by other dogs barking or even by the dog’s own vocalizations such as coughing or howling. Some bark collars have multiple settings so that they can be adjusted to the level of Correction that is appropriate for the dog’s size, temperament, and the behavior that is being corrected.

How long a dog wears a bark collar depends on the dog’s individual needs and the type of bark collar that is being used. In most cases, a bark collar is only worn during periods of time when the dog is likely to bark such as when the owner is not home or during outdoor activities. Once the dog has learned not to bark excessively, the bark collar can be removed.

Is It Safe To Use A Bark Control Collar?

Most dog owners want to know if it’s safe for their dogs to wear a dog bark control collar. Anti-bark collars stop your dog from barking by making an annoying ultrasonic noise that humans can’t hear, spraying citronella or lemon, or giving your dog a quick electric shock or vibration.

All of the things that interrupt are short and don’t have effects that last a long time.

The answer to the question of whether anti-bark collars are safe is yes. There are a few things to watch out for. Do not wear bark collars 12 hours straight because they can irritate your dog’s skin. Do not wear it while your dog is in a crate, sleeping, or having a good time playing.

best bark collars dog breeds


The popularity of bark collars has been on the rise in recent years as an increasing number of pet owners look to find ways to control their dogs’ barking. While these devices is effective for some, however, there is still a lot of debate about whether or not they are safe to use.

Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top