Pros and Cons of Dog Harness Vs Collar: Which Should You Get?

dog harness vs collar

When it comes to dog gear, pet owners are torn with dog harness vs collar. Some dog owners might not even know the difference, but there are actually some distinct pros and cons to each option. In this blog post, we will take a closer look at both dog collar and dog harness options, so that you can make an informed decision about what is best for your pup!

Dog Harness Vs Collar | What Is A Dog Collar?

dog harness vs collar

A dog collar is a piece of fabric or leather that loops around your dog’s neck and secures with a buckle. They are the most common type of dog gear.

They come in a wide variety of styles, colors, and materials. You can even find dog collars with fun patterns or charms!

Dog Harness Vs Collar| Types Of Collar:

no pull harness

Flat Collar:

A flat collar is the most common type of dog collar. It is made of a single piece of fabric or leather, and it secures with a buckle.

Martingale Collar:

A martingale dog collar is similar to a flat dog collar, but it has an extra loop of fabric that tightens when your dog pulls on the leash. This type of dog collar is often used for dogs that pull on the leash, as it helps to prevent them from slipping out of the collar.

Lucky Love Dog Martingale Collar | Premium No Slip Collar | Great for Whippets, Greyhounds, and More (Blackbird, Small)
  • 🤍LOOKING FOR AN EXTRA SPECIAL MARTINGALE COLLAR THAT STANDS OUT AND LOOKS GREAT ON YOUR DOG or PUPPY?  Lucky Love Dog specializes in...
  • 🤍CONVENIENT & RELIABLE – MARTINGALE COLLAR SLIPS OVER YOUR DOG’S HEAD & GETS YOU & YOUR DOG OUT THE DOOR QUICKLY! No buckles to worry...
  • 🤍YOUR LUCKY LOVE DOG PURCHASE WILL HELP SAVE A SHELTER DOG Good news… a portion of your Lucky Love Dog purchase is donated to help save a...

Slip Collar:

A slip collar is also similar to a flat collar, but it does not have a buckle. Instead, the fabric slips over your dog’s head and can be tightened if needed.

Slip collars are often used for training, as they allow you to quickly correct your dog’s behavior.

Flea And Tick Collar:

A flea and tick dog collar is a dog collar that is impregnated with chemicals that help to kill fleas and ticks. This type of dog collar can be helpful in preventing flea and tick infestations.

However, it is important to note that the chemicals can also be harmful to your dog if they are not used properly.

Dog Harness Vs Collar | What Is A Dog Harness?

dog harnesses

A dog harness is a piece of gear that loops around your pet’s body and secures with buckles or straps. It is a piece of gear that fits around your dog’s chest and back, securing at the shoulders and connecting to a leash at the back.

They are often used for dogs who pull on the leash, as they distribute weight more evenly across the body than a collar does.

Sale
rabbitgoo Dog Harness, No-Pull Pet Harness with 2 Leash Clips, Adjustable Soft Padded Dog Vest, Reflective No-Choke Pet Oxford Vest with Easy Control Handle for Large Dogs, Black, L
  • Large Dog Harness - Recommended Breeds: Medium to Large Dogs, such as Golden Retriever, Huskie, Labrador, Alaska, German Shepherd, Akita, etc....
  • No Pull, No Choke - Our non-pulling dog harness is specially designed with 2 metal leash rings for safer dog walks. Use the chest attachment clip...
  • Easy to Use - This hassle-free overhead harness is easy to put on and take off with its 2 fast-release buckles. Slide the harness over your dog's...

Harnesses are available in a wide variety of styles:

Back-Clip/Step-In Harness:

The back-clip dog harness is the most common type of dog harness. It secures at the shoulders and clips together at the back, near the base of the spine.

This type of dog harness is easy to put on and take off, and it provides a good range of motion for your dog especially during loose leash walking.

Front-Clip Harness

dog training

With a front-clip harness, you clip the leash to your dog’s chest in the middle. When you give it a gentle tug to turn your dog toward you, he or she will turn around.

With the back-clip harness, you don’t have much control over where your dog goes. With the front-clip harness, you can better direct where your dog goes.

Dual Clip Harness:

A dual clip dog harness has both a back and front clip, so you can decide which one to use depending on the situation. This type of dog harness gives you the most control over your dog’s movements.

The strongest connection to the leash is made by the back clip, but if your dog lunges or pulls in the wrong direction, the front clip tightens and you can easily steer him back on track.

Keep in mind that harnesses with two clips tend to cost more. Also, their webbed design may cause your dog’s shoulders to rub too much.

Tightening Harness:

A tightening dog harness is a dog harness that cinches closed when your dog pulls on the leash. This type of dog harness can be helpful in preventing dogs from slipping out, but it is important to note that it can also be harmful if used improperly.

You’ll need to make sure the harness doesn’t get too tight or your dog could get hurt, which could make him more aggressive.

Sale
Gooby Escape Free Easy Fit Harness - Hot Pink, Medium - No Pull Step-in Patented Small Dog Harness with Quick Release Buckle - Perfect On The Go No Pull Harness for Small Dogs or Medium Dog Harness
  • Escape Free Easy Fit Dog Harnesses for Small Dogs – Escape Free Easy Fit Step In Harness is made for small breed dogs. This means that our...
  • Escape Free Hot Pink Dog Harness - Our Escape Free Easy Fit dog harness no pull design reduces space around the back making harder for your dog...
  • Step In Deasign for Easy on and Easy Off – Our Step in dog harness design makes it easy for your dog to step in and step out the gooby harness...

Head Halter Harness:

A head halter dog harness is a dog harness that goes around your dog’s muzzle and over his head. This type of dog harness can be helpful in preventing dogs from pulling on the leash.

Most dog owners keep their dog’s attention on you as you walk. Clearly, this will stop your dog from acting distracted.

When your dog starts to pull or lunge, the tension on the leash moves your dog’s head down and toward you. This gentle reminder helps you walk with more control.

Dog Harness vs Collar: Which is Right for Your Dog?

What Are The Pros and Cons Of Dog Collar

dog breeds

Pros:

a. These are the most basic dog supplies, and they make it easy to keep ID tags and rabies tags around your pet’s neck.

b. There are different kinds of collars to try, this includes flat collars work for dogs that know how to walk on a leash without pulling.

c. Martingale collars (also called “limited slip collars”) are great for dogs whose necks are about the same size as their heads and can slip out of flat collars. Rolled collars work well to hold your dog’s ID but won’t flatten or mat the hair underneath them.

d. Depending on the size of your dog, a collar may give you better control and require less physical strength from you when you walk your dog than a harness.

e. Many dog trainers say that you should start leash training a puppy with a four-foot leash and a flat collar. Moreover, use positive reinforcement (like praise and treats) to get your dog to walk by your side.

f. Because they come in different styles and are made of different materials, they are easy to put on and take off, comfortable for your dog, stylish, and durable.

Cons:

a. If the collar is too big, your dog might be able to get out. This is especially true for dogs like Greyhounds and Whippets, whose heads are often smaller than their necks.

b. If it fits too tightly, it could bring too much pressure and could cause neck injury.

c. Collars for dogs can cause back pain, damage to the throat, and other kinds of pain.

french bulldogs

What Are The Pros And Cons Of A Dog Harness

Pros:

As a dog owner, make your dog feel more at ease.

a. Help stop your dog from running away.

b. Help puppies who don’t yet know how to walk on a leash.

c. Help keep small dogs from hurting themselves (like by damaging their throats) when they pull or tug on the leash.

d. Make sure your dog’s leash doesn’t get caught between his legs.

e. If you use a front-clip harness, it will help stop your dog from pulling.

f. Especially dogs with collapsed tracheas (a hacking cough often brought on by excitement, exercise, drinking water, or extreme temperatures).

g. Help a dog with back pain.

Cons:

a. Can be more difficult to put on and take off.

b. Depending on the size of the dog, you may need more power than you’d get from a conventional dog collar to walk your dog.

c. If your dog’s harness is too big then he or she might be able to get out of it and run away.

d. If a dog’s harness is too tight, it can cause too much pressure on your dog and can hurt them.

e. Can be unpleasant when it’s hot.

f. Back-hooking straps can genuinely teach your dog to pull you, which is the last thing you want.

5 Ways On How To Safely Use Dog Collars

Choose the Right Size

The dog collar should fit snugly around your dog’s neck without being too tight. Firstly you should be able to slip two fingers underneath the collar.

Check For Signs Of Wear And Tear

Inspect the dog collar regularly for signs of wear and tear, such as fraying or stretching. Furthermore, If you see any damage, replace the collar immediately.

Never Leave Your Dog Unattended In A Collar

Remove your dog’s collar before leaving him unattended, even for a short period of time. Dogs can get caught on objects while wearing collars, which could cause injury or death.

Harness Lead Escape Resistant Reduces Pull (Medium/Large, Blue Multi)
  • REDUCES PULL: REDUCES PULL: Gently tightens around barrel only. No tightening around neck. Utilizes a dog's own pressure against leash to...
  • ESCAPE RESISTANT: If dog attempts to back out of this harness, leash will tighten like a slip lead. Must be used according to directions. USE AS...
  • ADJUSTS TO ANY SIZE OR BODY TYPE: Align the movable black stops to line up with front leg and it will fit any body perfectly.

Choose The Right Type Of Collar

There are many different types of dog collars available apart from flat collars, martingale collars, and breakaway collars. Choose the type of collar based on your dog’s needs.

Use A Leash

When walking your dog, always use a leash to ensure he doesn’t run off and get lost or hurt.

Ways To Get Your Pet Used To A New Harness

Try out the harness before it goes on sale to the public.

This way you can get a feel for how it works and make sure that it is comfortable for your dog.

Start with short walks around the block. Nevertheless, help your dog get used to the new harness without feeling overwhelmed.

Learn that the harness means treats or fun.

Whenever you are using the harness try to use it together with toys or fun activities so your dog can associate it with good things.

Make sure the harness is comfortable.

The wrong size or fit can make your dog uncomfortable and cause chafing. When choosing a harness, make sure to take accurate measurements of your dog and consult sizing charts.

Take your time putting on the harness.

Rushing this process can make your dog anxious and stressed

Make sure the harness fits properly.

This is important for both comfort and safety. A good fitting dog harness will make it more likely that your dog will enjoy wearing it.

PetSafe Deluxe Easy Walk Dog Harness - Martingale Loop with D-ring Stops Pulling - Training & Behavior Aid - Reflectivity Enhances Visibility in Low Light - Comfortable Padding - Ocean/Black - M/L
  • LEGACY OF TRUST: This harness was created 15 years ago by a veterinary behaviorist and is trusted by a million dog parents and trainers each year
  • TEACHES BETTER LEASH MANNERS: Patented Martingale loop and front chest leash attachment minimizes your dog’s pulling by gently steering him in...
  • NO MORE GAGGING AND CHOKING: The harness safely controls light to moderate pulling by resting across your dog’s chest instead of his throat

Conclusion

A dog collar is a piece of clothing that goes around a dog’s neck. It has a buckle or clip to keep it in place and can have different attachments, such as tags, leashes, or ID collars. 

A dog harness attaches around a dog’s body and chest instead of their neck. This distributes the pulling force evenly across the dog’s body rather than putting all the pressure on their delicate necks

There are many types of dog collars and harnesses available on the market today. But I highly recommend the collars and harness sold in Regal. They have all the types of dog collars and harnesses that you need for your dog. Plus, the quality is top-notch, and the prices are unbeatable. So, if you’re looking for a dog collar or harness, be sure to check out RegalDogProducts.com today!

Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top