E Collar Not Working: Effective E Collar Solutions


In the world of dog training, electronic collars, commonly known as e-collars, have gained popularity for their effectiveness in training dogs. However, there are instances where pet owners might find that the e-collar isn’t always functioning correctly, properly or yielding the desired results. This article explores the potential reasons why an e-collar might not be working as expected and provides effective solutions to overcome these challenges.

Regal Dog Products Small Light Green Waterproof Dog Collar and Leash Set - Vinyl Coated Biothane Puppy Pet Training Collar with Heavy Duty Center Ring & 5ft Leash - Other Sizes for Medium & Large Dogs
  • ADJUSTABLE / CUSTOMIZABLE FIT: This biothane dog collar fits small, medium, large, and big dogs. It can be used for neck sizes ranging from 10.5...
  • PERFECT LEASH LENGTH: A 6’ ft. dog walking leash gets tangled in your dog’s feet and a 4’ ft. puppy lead is too short. Our research shows...
  • VIRTUALLY INDESTRUCTIBLE: This dog collar and leash are made from a synthetic material that has the look and feel of leather but is virtually...

What is a Dog Shock Collar?


A dog shock collar, also known as an electronic collar or e-collar, is a device used in dog training to provide a mild electrical stimulation to the dog.

This stimulation is intended to capture the dog’s attention and discourage certain behaviors. The collar consists of low battery, a receiver attached to a strap that goes around the dog’s neck, and a remote control held by the owner or trainer. The collar is equipped with different levels of intensity, ranging from very mild to slightly stronger sensations.

When the dog reacts and the owner or trainer presses a button on the remote control, a controlled electric pulse is delivered to the dog’s neck through the front receiver collar. However, it’s crucial to use these collars responsibly and under the guidance of a professional trainer. Misusing the collar or applying excessive force can cause stress, fear, and even physical harm to the dog.

How Does a Dog Shock Collar Work on a Dog’s Neck and Dog’s Skin?


A dog shock collar works by delivering a controlled and mild electric stimulation to the dog’s neck through the collar’s receiver. The collar receiver is designed to have contact points that rest against the dog’s skin, typically beneath its fur.

Here’s how the process works:

Transmission of Signal

When the owner or trainer presses a button on the remote control, a signal is sent wirelessly from remote transmitter to the collar’s receiver. This signal carries information about the selected intensity level and mode of stimulation.

Behavioral Association

The purpose of the electric stimulation is to capture the dog’s attention and interrupt its current behavior. Over time, through consistent training and positive reinforcement, the dog learns to associate the stimulation with specific commands or behaviors.

For example, if the dog is barking excessively, the owner might use the e-collar’s stimulation while giving the “quiet” command. It’s important to note that the goal of using a dog shock collar is not to cause pain or harm to the dog. Responsible usage involves using the lowest effective intensity level, employing positive reinforcement techniques, and adhering to ethical guidelines to ensure the dog’s well-being and comfort.

Is an E Collar Effective For Dod Training?


Yes, an e-collar can be effective for dog training when used responsibly and in conjunction with proper training techniques. E-collars, also known as electronic collars or shock collars, are designed to provide a mild and controlled electrical stimulation that can capture a dog’s attention and discourage undesirable behaviors. However, their effectiveness depends on several factors:

Proper Training

An e-collar should never be used as a standalone solution. Effective training involves teaching commands and behaviors using positive reinforcement techniques before introducing the e-collar. The collar then becomes a tool to reinforce those commands.

Clear Communication

E-collars can be effective in situations where clear communication is crucial, such as off-leash training or recall commands. The mild stimulation can help redirect a dog’s attention when it is engaged in unwanted behavior.


Consistency is key in dog training. Using the e-collar consistently and appropriately reinforces the dog’s understanding of commands and expectations.

Gradual Intensity

Starting with low intensity stimulation levels, and gradually increasing them helps the dog acclimate to the sensation and prevents overwhelming or distressing experiences.

Professional Guidance

Consulting a professional dog trainer with experience in e-collar training can help ensure that both you and are using the device correctly and effectively for your dog’s specific needs.

Positive Reinforcement

Positive reinforcement techniques from other dogs, such as treats, praise, and rewards, should accompany the e-collar training. This helps the dog associate the desired behavior with positive outcomes.

Adapting to Individual Dogs

Each dog is unique, and their responses to e-collar training can vary. Some dogs might be more sensitive, while others may need slightly stronger stimulation. A skilled trainer can tailor the training approach accordingly.

Avoiding Harm

It’s essential to prioritize the dog’s well-being. Responsible usage ensures that the e-collar is not causing harm or distress to the dog. Avoid using electronic devices with excessive force or high-intensity levels that might lead to fear or aggression.

Regal Dog Products Medium Red Waterproof Dog Collar with Heavy Duty Double Buckle & D Ring | Vinyl Coated, Custom Fit, Adjustable Biothane Dog Collar | Chew Resistant Waterproof Collar for Dogs
  • ADJUSTABLE / CUSTOMIZABLE FIT: This handmade water proof dog collar fits small, medium, large, and big dogs. It can be used for neck sizes...
  • VIRTUALLY INDESTRUCTIBLE: Our heavy duty waterproof dog collars are constructed with rust resistant, nickel-plated double buckle which lets the...
  • COMPLETELY WATERPROOF: Does your pup love the beach? This is the perfect collar for you! Vinyl-coated webbing is more durable than rubber, nylon,...

How to Use an E Collar as Dog Training Equipment


Using an e-collar as dog training equipment requires careful and responsible approach. Here’s a step-by-step guide on how to effectively and ethically use an e-collar for dog training:

Understand the Device

Familiarize yourself with the e-collar’s features, settings, and buttons. Understand how to adjust the battery intensity levels and choose different modes (e.g., vibration, sound).

Positive Association

Before introducing the e-collar, establish a positive association with the device. Additionally, let your dog sniff and explore the collar without any stimulation. Offer treats and praise to create a positive connection.

Professional Guidance

Consult a professional dog trainer experienced in e-collar training. Additionally, they can guide you on proper training collar usage techniques, intensity levels, and training protocols specific to your dog’s needs.

Basic Commands

Train your dog in basic commands using positive reinforcement techniques before introducing the e-collar.

Start with Low Intensity

Begin with the lowest intensity level. Press the button and observe your dog’s reaction. Additionally, it should be a surprising sensation, not painful. Furthermore, the goal is to capture attention, not cause distress.

Command and Stimulus

Use the e-collar simultaneously with a verbal command your dog is familiar with. For instance, if training the “come” command, use both the transmitter and e-collar’s stimulation when giving the command.

Positive Reinforcement

Immediately after using the e-collar, reward your dog with treats, praise, or toys for following the command correctly. Additionally, this reinforces the association between the stimulation and positive outcomes.


Consistency is crucial. Use the e-collar consistently with commands and behaviors you’ve already taught using positive methods.

E Collar Not Working: Increase Intensity Gradually

If your dog becomes accustomed to the first stimulation level, gradually increase the intensity as needed. Additionally, always monitor their response and adjust accordingly.

E Collar Not Working: Avoid Overuse

Don’t overuse the e-collar. Use it for specific training purposes, not as a constant accessory. Additionally, switch between regular collar and e-collar during training sessions.

E Collar Not Working: Observe Stress Signals

Watch for stress signals such as excessive scratching, vocalization, or anxious behavior. Additionally, if these signs occur, stop the training session and reassess the approach.

E Collar Not Working: Positive Outcome

Over time, your dog should respond to commands without needing the e-collar’s stimulation. Furthermore, the goal is to transition from e-collar-assisted training to relying on verbal cues.

E Collar Not Working: Regular Check-ins

Reevaluate your dog’s progress and behavior regularly. Additionally, adjust the training approach as needed based on their responses.

Regal Dog Products Cool Designer Collar | Adjustable Dog Collar with Custom fit for XS, Small, Medium, Large Dog, Cat, & Puppy | Fun Dog Gift Idea | Multiple Colors | Medium (12 inches to 18 inches)
  • 𝗣𝗿𝗲𝗺𝗶𝘂𝗺 𝗤𝘂𝗮𝗹𝗶𝘁𝘆:: With reinforced stitching our designer dog collar is handcrafted for durability and...
  • 𝗙𝗲?𝘁𝘂𝗿𝗲𝘀: The quick release buckle is fully adjustable with a side release buckle to fasten around your pet’s neck and a...
  • 𝗘𝘅𝗰𝗹𝘂𝘀𝗶𝘃𝗲 𝗗𝗲𝘀𝗶𝗴𝗻: Give your dog some style with a Regal Dog Products Teal / White Chevron Dog...

How to Fix an E Collar Not Working


If you’re facing issues with an e-collar not working as expected, it’s important to troubleshoot the problem before attempting any fixes. Here’s a step-by-step guide to help you address the issue:

E Collar Not Working: Check the Batteries

The most common reason for an e-collar not working is depleted batteries. Additionally, ensure that both the remote control and the e collar range’s receiver have fully charged batteries. Replace them if necessary.

E Collar Not Working: Check Intensity Settings

Verify that the intensity level on the e-collar is appropriately set. Additionally, start with the lowest setting and gradually increase if needed. A too-high intensity level can be overwhelming for the dog and hinder training.

E Collar Not Working: Inspect for Damage

Examine the collar, remote, and receiver for any visible damage or wear.

E Collar Not Working: Test Buttons

Press each button on the remote control to ensure they are working properly. Sometimes, a single button malfunction can affect the entire functionality of the remote collar.

E Collar Not Working: Check Signal Range

Move closer to your dog when testing the collar to test light it’s functionality. Sometimes, an insufficient signal range can result in the collar not responding from a distance.

E Collar Not Working: Test in Different Environments

Try testing the e-collar in various environments to get optimal performance and rule out any interference. Sometimes, factors like nearby electronic devices can affect the collar’s performance.

E Collar Not Working: Refer to the Manual

Consult the user manual that came with the e-collar for troubleshooting steps specific to your model. Additionally, the manual might provide insights into common issues and solutions.

Regal Dog Products Medium Black Heavy Duty Reflective Dog Collar with Durable Metal Buckle and D Ring | Adjustable, Chew Proof & Waterproof Dog Collar | Other Sizes for Small & Large Dogs
  • SAFETY AFTER SUNDOWN – Walking your dog in the dark is dangerous. Fetch some safety for both you and your furry friend with the Reflective Dog...
  • UNCATCH YOUR CANINE - If you are looking for an easy to clean and safety durable dog collar, have a look at our wide range of reflective...
  • DOGGONE DURABLE – Poorly made dog collars often break the first time your pooch lunges for a squirrel, but this thick dog collar is designed to...
Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top