Why Use a Dog Harness Instead of a Collar?

why use a dog instead of a collar

So, why use a dog harness instead of a collar?

As a dog owner, of course we all want our dogs to be happy and healthy. That means taking them on walks, giving their favorite treats, and giving them a lot of attention. Part of your bonding moments, involve going on regular walks.

When we take our dog to a dog park, we always want to make sure that they are getting along with other dogs. The best way to keep an eye on your dog is by using a dog collar or a dog harness.

extendable leashes

So, what’s the difference between the two? Well, a dog harness goes around your dog’s body and around your dog’s chest.

This allows for loose leash walking and gives your dog the freedom to go an explore within limits. On the other hand, flat collars goes around your dog’s neck while you walk dogs.

Given that both these devices are great for your dog, which one should you get? a collar vs dog harness?

The short explanation for this is, when a dog pulls and he’s wearing a collar, it could put a lot of strain on his neck. Whereas, if your dog is wearing a no pull harness, this gives him a lot of space to move around.

What are Dog Collars?

are retractable leashes bad

Dog collars and dog harnesses are both types of dog wear that serve various purposes, from restraining dogs during walks to training them not to pull on the leash.

Collars typically go around a dog’s neck and have a clasp or hook that attaches to a leash. On the other hand, harnesses fit around a dog’s torso and have one or two leads that clip onto the harness.

Both dog collars and dog harnesses can be made from a variety of materials, including leather, nylon, and fabric. Some dog collars even come equipped with GPS tracking devices, so you can always know where your furry friend is. So, whether you’re looking for a way to keep your dog restrained or simply want to stylishly accessorize them, consider investing in a dog collar or dog harness!

Dog Collar Pros

non retractable leash

A dog collar is both a necessity and a fashion statement. Every dog needs a collar, both for identification and for leash attachments. But collars also come in a wide variety of styles, colors, and materials, so they can be both functional and fashionable. And while some dog owners prefer to use harnesses, especially for large or strong dogs, many toy breeds and small dogs do better with collars.

There are several advantages to using a collar over a harness.


Collars are generally more comfortable for dogs, especially those with short necks like French bulldogs.


Collars are less likely to slip off than harnesses, so you don’t have to worry about your dog slipping out of his or her collar and getting lost.

walking dog on retractable leash


Collars provide easier access to your pet’s ID tag, so you can quickly see your dog’s information if he or she gets lost.

Overall, collars are the best choice for most dogs and their owners. Preferably small dogs, but it will also depend on your dog’s breed.

They’re comfortable, safe, and easy to use. So a harness has its own advantages on the first few harness walks as well. If you use it with both a collar or a harness, it can be useful to a working dog.

Dog Collar Cons

retractable leash vs regular

Apart from all the advantages to using a dog collar, there are also some disadvantages that you should consider.


If your dog is too small, and the collar is too loose, your dog can easily run away and escape. We want to prevent dog slips when going for a walk as much as we can. This is also very true for a large dog or long bodied breeds like German shepherds, who have heads that are sometimes bigger than their bodies. A rough tug by a tough mutt could cause too much pressure and lead to neck injury if they are wearing the wrong collar.


Dog collars like choke collars, a flat collar, choke chains, martingale collars, or prong collars may cause throat damage and discomfort in a brachycephalic breed.

Brachycephalic breeds are dogs like Boston terriers, French bulldogs, or pugs.

Many dogs feel uncomfortable with a collar causing trouble breathing. Remember that collars should only be used as a training tool because it keeps your dog safer from injury.

What Should You Consider When Choosing a Collar for your Dog’s Neck?

how do retractable leashes work

When it comes to choosing a collar for your dogs, there are a few things you’ll want to keep in mind. For starters, you’ll want to consider what type of collar will give you better control over your pup.

If you’re looking for more control during walks, then a body harness might be a better option than a traditional neck collar.

However, if you’re simply looking for a way to ID your dog, then a neck collar is probably all you need.

You’ll also want to keep the size and breed of your dog in mind when choosing a collar. For example, small breeds typically need narrower collars than larger breeds. And finally, you’ll want to consider your personal preferences.

Some people prefer the look of a traditional neck collar, while others find wearing harnesses to be more comfortable. Ultimately, regardless if you choose a collar or harness, the choice is up to you!

Why Use a Dog Harness Instead of a Collar: Different Types of Dog Harnesses

rabbitgoo Dog Harness, No-Pull Pet Harness with 2 Leash Clips, Adjustable Soft Padded Dog Vest, Reflective No-Choke Pet Oxford Vest with Easy Control Handle for Large Dogs, Black, L
  • Adjustable Dog Harness - Recommended Breeds: Small to Large Dogs, such as Golden Retriever, Huskie, Labrador, Alaska, German Shepherd, Akita,...
  • No Pull, No Choke - Our non-pulling dog harness is specially designed with 2 metal leash rings for safer dog walks. Use the chest attachment clip...
  • Easy to Use - This hassle-free overhead harness is easy to put on and take off with its 2 fast-release buckles. Slide the harness over your dog's...

Not all dog harnesses are made the same. Understanding that there are two main types of well fitting harness we be useful for a new dog.

Body Harness

The body harness is best for working dogs. This type of harness fits evenly around a dog’s center and evenly distributes the pressure from a leash. Working dogs that wear harnesses like this, use a harness to pull heavy loads.

The harness fits the dogs whole body, which makes it easy for the dog to pull anything when they use a harness.

When is It Best to Use It?

A body harness is better for an older dog who has an orthopedic disease or trouble breathing. It’s also best for certain breeds that are a lot smaller.

When Not to Use It

Do not use a body harness if you have a dog that has skin issues. Additionally, do not use this on a dog that is too hyperactive. It won’t reduce pulling and make the problem worse. Yes, it could give you more control, but it will also make it easy for your dog to pull you along with the leash.

Front Clip Harnesses

A front clip harness is perfect for hyperactive pups. It’s designed slightly like a body harness, only it has a front clip and a metal ring which makes it easier to control.

Front clip harnesses often partially restrict movement in the shoulders, which makes it a good training tool for many breeds.

When is It Best to Use It?

This type of harness is better used for training. A lot of professional trainers from the American Kennel Club use a harness to train dogs. It keeps hyper active dogs focused and controlled every time.

When Not to Use It

A front clip harness is primarily used for training and not a long term solution. If you have managed to teach your dog not to pull already, using a front clip harness can actually be a bit damaging for them.

Since these harnesses fit snuggly around the shoulders, using one for too long can alter a dog’s natural want to walk.

Why Use a Dog Harness Instead of a Collar: Reasons Why Dog Harnesses are Better than Using Dog Collars

retractable dog leash good or bad

Have you ever been out for a walk with your dog, only to have them suddenly bolt after a squirrel or another person? It can be really scary, not to mention dangerous.

If your dog is strong and determined enough, they can easily slip out and take off into another person’s yard even while you have your hands firmly on the leash.

This is where a harness comes in handy. A harness gives you more control over your dog without hurting them the way a collar can. And if you’re worried about your dog’s fashion sense, don’t worry – there are plenty of stylish harnesses available that will let your pup express their personality while still staying safe on walks.

So why not ditch the collar and opt for a harness instead? Here are some good reasons to consider getting a harness with a leash:

Better Control

Not every dog will obey your orders like an angel. This is why you need to have full control when your going for a walk with your dog. Using a harness gives you better control over an active dog, which prevents them from running off. People with big dogs can benefit heavily from a harness, especially when they get excited.

Reduces Pulling When Walking Dogs

For many dog owners, taking their furry friend for a walk is one of the highlights of the day. But for some, it can be a frustrating experience if their dog is constantly pulling on the leash. A dog harness can help to reduce pulling and make walks more enjoyable for both owner and pup.

Voyager Step-in Air Dog Harness - All Weather Mesh Step in Vest Harness for Small and Medium Dogs by Best Pet Supplies - Harness (Fuchsia), Small
55,565 Reviews
Voyager Step-in Air Dog Harness - All Weather Mesh Step in Vest Harness for Small and Medium Dogs by Best Pet Supplies - Harness (Fuchsia), Small
  • ATTENTION: Sizing does NOT directly correspond to your pet's breed or weight. Please MEASURE your pet by printing out our Size Guide which has a...
  • ALL WEATHER MESH: Made with a soft, breathable air mesh, this lightweight pet harness is perfect for walks all year round.
  • REFLECTIVE BANDS: Two reflective bands on the sides of this harness enhance your pet’s visibility for those early morning and late evening...

Prevents Neck Injuries

imagine this scenario: you’re out for a walk with your pup, enjoying a lovely day. Suddenly, your dog sees a rabbit and takes off after it, jerking you forward. You instinctively grab the leash to stop him, but in doing so, you pull on his neck.

Ouch! Now imagine that same scenario with a harness. When your dog takes off after the rabbit, the pressure is distributed across his chest instead of his neck, preventing any neck injuries (for both you and your pup!).

In addition to preventing injuries, harnesses also provide extra control when walking dogs who are particularly strong or excitable.

Prevents Ocular Proptosis in Some Dog Breeds

Just like people, dogs come in all shapes and sizes. And just like people, some dogs are prone to certain health problems. For example, did you know that some breeds are prone to a condition called ocular proptosis? Ocular proptosis is a condition where the eyeball actually pops out of the socket.

Fortunately, there is a way to prevent this from happening: by using a dog harness. Dog harnesses help to distribute the weight of the body evenly, preventing strain on the muscles and ligaments around the eye.

In addition, dog harnesses can help to protect the eyeball from being hit or scratched. As a result, they are an essential piece of gear for any dog owner who is concerned about their pet’s eye health.

Makes your Dog Unable to Escape

A harness provides additional security, making it difficult for your dog to wiggle out of it and run off. In addition, a harness can also provide more control when walking a strong or energetic dog.

Instead of being pulled along by your pet, you can guide them more easily with a harness. Whether you’re concerned about your dog’s safety or just tired of chasing them around, a harness is definitely worth considering.

PetSafe Easy Walk No-Pull Dog Harness - The Ultimate Harness to Help Stop Pulling - Take Control & Teach Better Leash Manners - Helps Prevent Pets Pulling on Walks - Medium, Apple Green/Gray
  • HELPS STOP PULLING: Patented Martingale loop design puts gradual pressure on your dog’s shoulders to safely and effectively stop pulling; a...
  • LEGACY OF TRUST: Created by a veterinary behaviorist in 2004, the Easy Walk harness is loved and trusted by a million pet parents and trainers
  • COMFORTABLE FIT: Easy Walk harness has less coverage than other harnesses making it lightweight and very breathable

Prevents Respiratory Problems

Harnesses are a great way to keep your dog safe and comfortable, especially if they tend to pull on the leash. But did you know that harnesses can also help to prevent problems with regards to your pups respiratory system? When dogs pull on their leash, they put strain on their neck and throat, which can lead to tracheal collapse.

This condition is often seen in small breeds, and it can be very dangerous. A harness takes the pressure off of your canine’s neck and distributes it evenly across their body, which helps to prevent tracheal collapse.

So, not only are harnesses more comfortable for your dog, but they can also help to keep them healthy.

But of course, if you prefer dog collars, we have in our store a wide selection of dog collars for your beloved pet. Check out our dog collars!

Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top